100 most important issues for the future of global agriculture
ReadingsNote:
In 2010, International Journal of Agricultural Sustainability, Volume 8, Issue 4 published an important article entitled The top 100 questions of importance to the future of global agriculture (100 most important issues in global agriculture in the future). From the title, we can see the significance of this article, although it is only the views and opinions of some scholars.
Domestic scholars Wang Songliang and Cao Zhiquan have translated this article. The following is reproduced from the network translation.
Thanks to the two translators!
Recommended by Du Zhixiong
100 most important issues for the future of global agriculture
2012-09-29 Author: Jules Pretty
1. Preface
although global food production has increased significantly in the past half century, one of the most important challenges that society needs to face today is how to feed the 9 billion population that the world is about to reach by the middle of the 21st century. In order to meet food demand without significantly increasing food prices, based on the impact of climate change, concerns about energy security, changes in regional dietary patterns, and the Millennium Goal of halving global poverty and hunger by 2015, it is estimated that world food production will increase by 70%-100% or more than at present [1,2]. In addition, new ways should be found to remedy unequal access to food. Although we have produced enough food to feed the entire population of the planet, more than 1 billion people still suffer from food insecurity and malnutrition. In many parts of the world, this challenge is exacerbated by increasing purchasing power and changing dietary habits, especially in poorer regions, accompanied by barriers to food access and distribution, and the pressure to achieve the Millennium Development Goal of halving world poverty and hunger by 2015 [3-6].
While there have been many agricultural innovations and technological advances in recent decades, several of these issues pose new and more complex challenges to today's global agriculture, which is already under pressure to achieve a sustainable environment and society with food production and energy security [7]. What is more, the past five years have already seen the extreme impact of volatile food prices on poor areas, particularly during the price peak of 2007-2008 [8], and the political and scientific debate on the role of biofuels in influencing total carbon stocks and carbon emissions [9-11]. Undoubtedly, changes in land use patterns (regardless of use) are an important factor in global change [12-15]. Agriculture and food systems are estimated to account for one-third of global greenhouse gas emissions and twice as much as transportation [15,16]. Therefore, the goal of the agricultural sector is not simply to increase productivity, but to optimize regional production, rural development, environmental protection and socially equitable resource distribution [2,3,17].
Recently, there has been a growing recognition of the complexity of the driving forces facing global agriculture [4,6,7]. However, the development of domestic and international policies that can support more widely sustainable land use and more efficient agricultural production methods is a serious challenge for both industrialized and developing countries [5]. Despite the increasing emphasis on evidence-based decision-making, the complexity of the flow of information between scientists, practitioners and policymakers, and often a lack of communication, exacerbates the difficulty of the problem [18-21]. In this paper, we aim to promote dialogue and understanding between agricultural research and policy by identifying 100 issues (hereinafter collectively referred to as "overarching issues") that are of paramount importance to global agriculture in the future. These top questions are compiled by experts and representatives of the world's major agricultural organizations, with the aim of guiding decision makers through detailed scientific evidence to formulate research priorities and policy support projects for the future of agriculture. Just as policy development needs to be guided by scientific knowledge and priorities, scientific research must focus on issues that can influence current and future policy frameworks and are relevant to the needs and concerns of farmers and agricultural workers around the world, so that public science and policy institutions can be forward-looking and not passive [22]. It is worth noting that although the 100 primary issues we propose next are general and universal, the solutions to agricultural problems in various regions should often be based on specific historical and cultural backgrounds.
The prospect screening approach used in this paper has previously been applied by policy makers as well as practitioners and researchers in the ecological research and environmental sectors to identify issues related to ecology and conservation biology [23,24]. It is based on consultations with representatives of professionals from the world's major conservation organizations, academics and universities, and is aimed at researchers who need to make their work more applicable to practical conservation work or those organizations that evaluate and locate the Fund's projects. In this paper, the 100 overarching questions are based on consultations between representatives of 37 Commonwealth government agencies, non-governmental organizations and academia. Since 2006, a series of collaborative exercises on identifying priority issues and developing new policies and issues have been conducted in the United Kingdom, the United States and Canada [24-26].
Our goal is to identify 100 top issues in agriculture that, if addressed, could make a significant contribution to global agricultural practices and strengthen synergies between agricultural policy, practice and research. In order to achieve this goal, we adopt a collaborative and inclusive prospect screening approach, which is a method that can maximize the openness and integration of different opinions and has scientific rigor [20]. To this end, we have brought together senior representatives and experts from agricultural organizations, scientific associations and non-governmental academic research institutions from all over the world with a variety of associations with the beneficiaries of this study, including farmers and policy makers. The aim is to let the listed priority issues guide the policy support projects and priority scientific research projects of agriculture in the next few years. Our audience is therefore decision-makers guiding future agricultural policy and research, as well as researchers dedicated to agricultural scientific research. Some of the questions selected in this study will be the primary questions for future agricultural research. This paper reports on the final list of selected issues and discusses each of them in light of the current state of agriculture. The study is part of the UK Government's Future Global Food and Farming project.
2. Research data and methods
the core team members come from various disciplines, including senior representatives and experts from the world's major agricultural organizations, scientific societies and academic institutions, and then the core team members identify the top 100 issues in global agriculture and food. This brings together 45 organizations from around the world, most of which are based in Western Europe and North America, but because they are internationally entrusted, most of the representatives have agricultural experience outside the region. Team members are informed of procedures and obligations when invited, and the final core team is 55 senior representatives from 21 countries. The author list of this article lists their personal details and the name of their organization.
The final formation of these 100 primary issues went through a three-stage process.
First, all core team members must broaden their networks in their areas of expertise and consult with their colleagues in the organization to come up with a list of priority issues. Core team members should brainstorm, deliberate, and consult with people outside their specialty [20]. Questions must be solicited in a variety of ways, including panels, working sessions and seminars and E-mail exchanges, for other members of the same organization to recommend solvable issues that do not have a reliable knowledge background. These questions must meet the following evaluation criteria:(1) the questions can be answered through research design;(2) the answers to the questions must be based on facts and not from subjective value judgments;(3) the questions must have not been answered;(4) the implementation process and impact of the relevant questions should have clear objectives and results;(5) the questions should not be true or false;(6) The size of the problem must be theoretically such that a team of workers can attempt to find a solution in a reasonable way. The ideal problem itself can be used as a research topic, or it can be divided and transformed into many more direct branches of research [27]. 618 questions were selected (submitted with the name of the proposer and his organization). The 618 selected issues were grouped into the following 14 agriculture-related priority research themes:(1) climate, watersheds, water sources and aquatic ecosystems;(2) soil nutrition, erosion and fertilizer use;(3) biodiversity, ecosystem services and conservation;(4) energy, climate change and ecosystem restoration;(5) crop production systems and technologies;(6) crop genetic improvement;(7) pest management;(8) domestic livestock and poultry;(9) social capital, gender equality and agricultural extension;(10) agricultural development and farmers' livelihoods;(11) the relationship between governance, economic investment, power and decision-making;(12) food supply chains;(13) prices, markets and trade; and (14) consumption patterns and health. Secondly, the core team is broken down into 14 expert groups, each consisting of 3-5 experts, each with a focal point responsible for promoting and developing a specific topic, while the core team members are invited to participate in the expert groups they wish to participate in as much as possible, without specifically limiting the number of experts in a given expert group. The task of the expert group is to browse, revise, integrate or rewrite the original questions in the field (in this case, the name and affiliation of the person who proposed the original question need to be hidden to reduce possible bias) to ensure simplicity, avoid duplication, and add new questions that are not mentioned. Then, each field is classified into 5 necessary problems and 10 possible problems. The possible problems are relatively flexible and determined by the expert team. Necessary problems are defined as problems that have a major impact on global agriculture and food systems. The remaining questions are discarded. In this process, sorting the questions should be avoided, so as not to hinder the breadth of the problem [20]. In order to increase the transparency of participation, questions from the 14 priority areas were distributed to core team members in electronic form, giving each participant the opportunity to improve on any area, resulting in 70 necessary questions and 146 possible questions related to each topic. Finally, the 70 necessary questions identified by the expert group will be automatically included in the final 100 top questions, and the remaining 30 top questions will be selected from 146 possible questions through electronic voting conducted by the Secretariat. Each core team member can select up to 30 possible questions. Core team members must go through and vote on all possible questions, not questions that are limited to their area of interest. In the end, there were 1385 votes. At various stages, core team members can modify and reinterpret the issue to make it more relevant to the topic. Finally, the voting results are summarized and the votes for each issue are calculated. The top 30 issues with the highest votes are selected as the top 100 issues, which are then handed over to the core team members for final revision.
3. Research results and analysis
we have organized the 100 top issues into the following four components of the agricultural production system:(1) natural resource inputs;(2) agronomic practices;(3) agricultural development; and (4) markets and consumption.
There is some overlap between different topics, such as the concern for the genetic improvement of crops, which often relates to the protection of biodiversity, and the issue of livestock, which is often related to the issue of climate change, but we ensure that there is no duplication in the final list of issues. The last 100 top issues are not in order of priority.
Part I Natural Resource Inputs
1. climate, waters, water resources and aquatic ecosystems
climate change projections point to global warming over the next 50 years, but are uncertain about the impact of rising temperatures on rainfall distribution patterns in most parts of the world [16]. Coastal ocean temperatures have been shown to rise three to five times faster than predicted by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), and marine ecosystems, which absorb 50% of the world's carbon, continue to suffer. From the perspective of global food security, many commercial fish species are facing economic extinction, and recent surveys show that 63% of the global marine fish reserves require intensive management to rebuild their biomass and species diversity due to overexploitation [29].
Actions need to be implemented across different scales, from small fields to communities, catchments, small watersheds, and finally entire river basins. The implementation needs to pay attention to increase the use efficiency of "green water (water in soil aquifers)" and "blue water (water in reservoirs, lakes, groundwater reservoirs)" [30]. In some countries, 85% of diverted water resources are now diverted to agriculture, which competes fiercely with urban and industrial uses. For this reason, especially in response to climate change, there is a need for continuous improvement in crop, soil and water management. The overarching questions in this section are as follows:
Question 1: What is the significant impact of climate change (e. g., temperature, wind speed, humidity, water availability, storm intensity, agricultural water demand, changes in snowmelt and seasonal runoff, number of pests, degree of waterlogging, transformation of agro-ecosystems, population migration) on agricultural yields, cultivation techniques, spread of crop pests and diseases, disease resistance and irrigation development?
Question 2: If the existing reserves of environmental resources are to be maintained, what is the cost of setting a global cap on agricultural water consumption?
Question 3: What is the impact of increased rainwater harvesting on local hydrological flows? How can changes in local hydrological flows integrate and transform the availability of water resources on a larger geographical scale?
Question 4: How can aquaculture and open water fish rearing be developed to minimize impacts on wild fish populations and coastal aquatic habitats?
Question 5: What agricultural methods (agronomic, genetic, operational, assisted irrigation schemes, land fertility management, winter precipitation storage) should be developed to improve water use efficiency? What are the cost-effectiveness of these methods?
Question 6: In arid and semi-arid areas, how can forestry, agroforestry, grass cover, water storage facility systems, drought-resistant crops and water-saving technologies be combined to increase food production? And to what extent can this combination be most effective?
Question 7: How to optimize the allocation of water resources between irrigated agriculture and environmental protection functions? And what innovative policies and technologies can minimize the trade-offs between irrigation and the healthy functions of natural ecosystems?
2. soil nutrition, erosion, and fertilizer use
soil fertility management is essential to improve and maintain agronomic and biological productivity. The nutrient needs of the crop harvest (I. e. cereals, roots, tubers and stalks, fruits, wood) should be compensated to ensure that the natural nutrient capital of the soil is not owed. Only with appropriate inputs to balance the yield of all production outputs can an agro-ecosystem that is so intensively managed be sustainable in the long run. Balancing the yield achieved, whether through plant nutrition provided by organic methods (biofertilizers) or inorganic methods (synthetic fertilizers), is a matter of the logistics, availability, price, environmental impact and scale of nutrient sources and sinks being assessed. Plants do not distinguish whether the nutrients obtained are organic or inorganic, and it is crucial that the nutrients are available in sufficient quantities and in appropriate form. and nutrient availability that is most appropriate for crop growth and yield formation at specific phenophase. The supply of manure, compost and other biological fertilizers can have a positive impact on soil physical, chemical and biomass for equivalent nutritional requirements. However, the huge amount of nutrients required for 0.15 billion hectares of arable land (5-10 mg/ha/year) raises very clear logistical issues of nutrient availability, transport and supply.
Excessive loss of fertile soil surface layers by water and soil erosion is an important form of soil degradation and leads to desertification. Since soil organic matter and plant nutrients are concentrated in the top soil, these materials are preferentially removed along with the clay fraction. In addition to the loss of nutrient reserves and the reduction of effective root depth, the loss of runoff water and the long-term reduction of available water capacity will also adversely affect crop growth and yield. Soil degradation caused by the loss of nutrients and soil organic carbon stocks, as well as exacerbated by the permanent use of extractive farming practices, is a major problem in developing countries such as sub-Saharan Africa, South Asia, South-East Asia and the Caribbean. The overarching questions in this section are as follows:
question 8: What are the benefits of sustainable soil management for agricultural production and other ecosystem services?
Question 9: How should subsistence farmers make the most efficient use of organic fertilizers in order to increase soil nutrients and water retention capacity to help restore the entire agro-ecosystem?
Question 10: What are the most practical and economical ways to manage soil fertility in paddy fields and mountain production systems in the tropics?
Question 11: How can poor smallholder farmers be instructed to ensure that nitrogen fertilizer management increases their soil organic carbon without net mineralization?
Question 12: How to prevent and improve the phenomenon of soil salinization?
Question 13: How can native soil organisms be used to maximize food productivity and reduce environmental impact?
Question 14: What is the status of the world's usable phosphate reserves? Are these reserves sufficient to supply global food production in the next century?
3. biodiversity, ecosystem services and conservation
agriculture has been a major cause of global biodiversity loss, altering natural habitats, such as converting forests and wetlands to cropland [31]. In addition, the increase in agricultural efficiency has led to a sharp decline in species that use arable land as habitat. Increased use of man-made pesticides, herbicides, and fertilizers has been a key driver of environmental change; increased homogenization of landscapes due to regional and farm specialization; poor drainage in low-lying areas, patch damage at the edge of cultivated land and those habitats without crop distribution; and reduced fallow time within cropland rotation [32-34]. In addition, intensive agriculture is already a major factor in the degradation of ecosystem services, both increasing greenhouse gas production and reducing carbon sequestration [35]. The main challenge is to understand the best compromise between increasing food production while reducing adverse impacts on biodiversity, ecosystem services and human society. Increased global food production must come from increased yields on arable land or an expansion of farmland. In addition, new technologies will increase agricultural intensification and areas suitable for farming, such as through the selection and cultivation of drought-resistant crops, and the best compromise is based on a better understanding of how to use new technologies, agroenvironmental plans and balance intensification and intensification to ensure sustainable food production, ecosystem services, biodiversity and socio-economic impacts. The overarching questions in this section are as follows:
question 15: What is the relationship between productivity and biodiversity (and/or other ecosystem services), and how does this change between agricultural systems and spatial scales where land is used only for food production functions?
Question 16: How should the choice be made between intensive, extensive, habitat restoration or status quo maintenance, and how should economic, ecological and social benefits be balanced?
Question 17: What are the different environmental consequences of planting drought-resistant crops in different regions?
Question 18: What are the consequences for the conservation of biodiversity and the realization of other ecosystem services if crop and livestock management are planned with greenhouse gas emission reduction targets?
Question 19: In intensive production systems, what agricultural environmental protection measures can be used to create a buffer zone between protected areas, or natural and semi-natural habitats, or "soft the matrix" between these landscape patches?
Question 20: Which restored natural habitats provide the greatest amount of food and environmental benefits for human society?
Question 21: How can improved technologies, farming practices, systems and policies be combined to maintain ecosystem services, including soil fertility, in developing countries that are engaged in intensive agriculture, particularly in sub-Saharan Africa?
Question 22: Can the payment of ecosystem services (e. g. carbon sequestration, green water credits and biodiversity enhancement) lead to the adoption of recommended land use and management practices by resource-poor farmers in developing countries?
4. energy, climate change and ecological restoration
as the demand for energy will continue to grow in the coming decades, alternative energy sources will need to be found to sustain the needs of a growing global population. Agriculture consumes a lot of energy, which can be used directly in machinery or implicit in products used in agriculture [36]. The impact of high oil prices on low-income rural households and global agricultural inputs (pesticides and nitrogen fertilizers), transportation, farming and irrigation systems will lead to reduced agricultural productivity, thereby increasing the pressure to expand arable land at low levels of productivity [15].
Climate change is one of the greatest challenges facing humanity today, and it will affect agriculture in many ways, both positively and negatively. The need for agriculture to adapt to climate change and the need to reduce greenhouse gas emissions from agriculture to mitigate climate change further exacerbate the already significant challenge of producing more food with fewer inputs [37]. In the coming decades, recovery from climate change will become an important feature of sustainable agricultural production systems, especially in areas where dramatic ecological changes due to a changing climate are expected. The overarching questions in this section are as follows:
question 23: What is the best option for agriculture to increase food production while reducing greenhouse gas emissions?
Question 24: What are the risks of mass migration from adverse climate change and how will it affect agricultural production systems?
Question 25: Given that a large amount of energy is directly or indirectly invested in agriculture, how can carbon neutrality be used to make food production meet the goal of energy saving and emission reduction in the next 40 years?
Question 26: How will different market payment mechanisms, such as greenhouse gas emission reduction or carbon storage, affect farming and how can they be implemented appropriately?
Question 27: How can the demand for land for food production and energy production be most effectively balanced to ensure the value of ecosystem services while maintaining appropriate yields and prices?
Question 28: How can the resilience of agricultural production systems be improved to cope with both moderate climate change and high and extreme weather?
Question 29: What combination of intensive and extensive is most appropriate to increase production, reduce greenhouse gas emissions and increase ecosystem services?
Question 30: How can crop breeding, new technologies, traditional cultivation techniques and improved farming techniques be balanced to increase food production and improve resilience in the face of future climate change?
Question 31: How can biorefining technologies be used to best transform the "hydrocarbon-based economy" into a "carbohydrate-based economy" that, in addition to maintaining current food production, can process agricultural products into high-value products, biomaterials, energy sources and soil amendments?
Question 32: How can the long-term carbon sequestration capacity of agricultural land be best achieved (e. g. through soil management practices, perennial crops, trees, ponds, biochar applications)?
Question 33: How can the application of carbon market mechanisms to agriculture bring significant benefits to farmers?
Part II: Agronomic Measures
1. crop production systems and technologies
in order to meet the growing demand for food and feed brought about by population growth and the expansion of the working class in the 21st century, global crop production must increase by 70%-100%[1,2]. In addition, due to land and water constraints, significant increases in crop yields must be achieved through increased conversion of scientific and technological achievements, thereby promoting sustainable intensification of crop and livestock production systems [2,4,6,7,38].
Strategies that tend to differentiate between agro-based biotechnology and organic systems are just beginning to receive the attention they deserve from the scientific community [6,39]. For example, the coexistence of organic agriculture and GM technology often lacks a common understanding. There is a new saying that what we need is not a single path, but many sustainable intensification paths based on a variety of systems (from fallow rotation, mixed agriculture and forestry, mixed agriculture and animal husbandry, mixed fish and farming systems to no-tillage and precision agriculture), applicable to a large number of specific agro-ecological and socio-economic sustainable intensification paths. This will be increasingly important to understand how science-based efforts can address real-world challenges and, in different contexts, produce outcomes conducive to sustainable intensification. The overarching questions in this section are as follows:
question 34: What are the benefits and risks associated with the use of different types of agricultural biotechnology (e. g. environmental impact; sensitivity/resistance to environmental loads such as heat, drought, salinity, etc.; dependence on or exemption from the use of additives; risk of accelerated resistance, food safety, human health and nutrition; socio-economic impact)?
Question 35: What are the advantages and disadvantages of organic production systems in terms of biodiversity, ecosystem services, yields and human health, especially in resource-poor developing countries?
Question 36: How can effective measures be taken to break the conceptual barriers between organic biology and genetic modification, so as to fully exploit the potential effectiveness of combining genetically modified crops with organic production models, so that agro-ecosystem management measures can be compatible with sustainable intensive farming practices?
Question 37: What is the long-term supply of fossil fuels and fertilizers such as nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium under the intensive production system currently used globally?
Question 38: How can a food production system be designed to reduce dependence on nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium additives?
Question 39: How to establish a set of criteria that are suitable and commonly accepted by different agro-ecological, political, economic and social situations to monitor the process of achieving sustainability in different agro-ecosystems?
Question 40: What role will wasteland reclamation, renewal and restoration play in global food production?
Question 41: If climate and market risks, farmers' assets and farmers' own circumstances are taken into account, what is the best option for integrated farming and mixed farming systems to address different agro-ecological and socio-economic situations (including fallow rotation, local cultivation of cereals, tubers and other staple foods, mixed agroforestry, mixed farming and mixed farming and mixed farming systems)?
genetic improvement of 2. crops
by the time crops were first domesticated for food, fiber, and fodder, about 10,000 years ago, humans had been able to benefit from the effective exploitation of crops by extensive screening for the genetic diversity readily encountered in most crop varieties and their close relatives [40]. However, true science-based crop breeding was only just beginning into the 20th century [41]. Over the past century, humans have relied on a limited number of crop varieties, but their yields and quality have increased significantly. For example, China's yields of corn, rice, and wheat have increased by 36%, 25%, and 60%, respectively, compared to 20 years ago [42]. In the first fifty years after the turn of the last century, most of the progress made came from crop hybridization (including interspecific hybridization), followed by artificial breeding. Subsequently, a range of techniques, including tissue culture, mutant screening, genetic transformation, and a range of molecular marker-assisted selection methods, have enabled people to explore, create, and exploit genetic diversity more effectively [43]. The Green Revolution of the 1960 s emerged from selection for semi-dwarf traits in wheat and rice, which doubled yields [44,45]. For other crops, such as corn and vegetables, the advent of genetic technology has enabled the exploitation of heterosis and crop uniformity and has had a dramatic impact on productivity [44,46].
However, although plant breeding has made a great contribution to the improvement of crop yield and quality, there are still some crop categories, geographical areas or planting environments that have not received more investment. Of course, the production potential of crops is also affected by biologically relevant physical factors [47]. At the same time, the growing emphasis on creating crop production systems with high resource efficiency and low greenhouse gas emissions has begun to change the prioritization of trait genetic improvement program objectives [44,48]. Crop quality for livestock and human nutrition also remains a priority area of research [49]. In addition, public, private, and public interest investment in the genetic improvement of crops has been stimulated and constrained by intellectual property protection [50] and technical standards [47] for the past two decades. This involves, inter alia, patenting and restricted licensing of genes, advanced technologies that promote gene identification, gene transfer, targeted mutations, and regulatory frameworks that have been developed to assess and respond to known risks. The overarching questions in this section are as follows:
question 42: How can we respond to biotic and abiotic stresses by improving resource efficiency through genetic modification of crops?
Question 43: How can we significantly reduce greenhouse gas emissions from agriculture and horticulture through improved crop varieties?
Question 44: What are the comparative benefits of crop development with different genetic approaches to abiotic stress tolerance, such as frost, high temperature, drought, soil ponding, and acid and salt poverty?
Question 45: What are the effects of different genetic modifications to improve the efficiency of nutrient use in crops while increasing their production?
Question 46: What is the impact of genetic modification of crops on the uptake of micro-nutrients by humans, livestock and fish?
3. Pest Management
new pests and diseases continue to destroy crop yields, which has not been noticed by farmers and agricultural scientists. The history of pest research has focused on large pests and diseases that cause catastrophes and often require urgent research. There will be new problems in the future, perhaps more urgent than large pests and diseases, just as climate change has changed the relationship between crops and pests in unforeseen ways.
Research and development in integrated pest management (IPM) has made substantial progress since 1960. From the classical biological control and host-plant resistance as the beginning, to more recent targeted plant species diversification methods, such as "push-pull" technology ('push-pull' techniques )[51] and other landscape management methods to enhance biological control, IPM has become essentially the most basic management of pests and diseases in agroecology. However, despite its success in bringing multiple benefits to farmers and society, the research and application of IPM still lags behind [7]. However, the current trend of pest research is inclined to insects, diseases second, and weeds third. The input for research expansion needs to be proportional to the loss of pest formation. More recently, funding-driven and academic pest research has been biased towards integrated pest management (IPM) for alternative chemicals. At the same time, the industry mainly contributes to the research of new technologies, for example, the development of insect-resistant genetically modified organisms, insecticides that are fatal to insects but less toxic to vertebrates (such as chitin growth inhibitors). The future needs more meaningful investment between technologies. IPM has contributed to increasing food production, but it can only help reduce poverty and hunger by developing a new generation of technologies that control the loss of bedbugs, birds, weeds and microorganisms during the pre-and post-harvest process. The threat of global climate change makes adaptive management and rapid innovation all the more urgent to address the threat of future agricultural development. The overarching questions in this section are as follows:
question 47: What is the evidence that climate change will change the incidence of pests and diseases?
Question 48: How can agricultural deinsectization be modified to reduce the evolution of drug resistance in mosquitoes and other major pathogens of human disease?
Question 49: How does landscape-scale intervention contribute to pest management? Which approach is most consistent with the principles of economic and social sustainability?
Question 50: How can perennial farming systems, including overburden crops, be used as a form of pest management? What are the economic and non-economic costs and benefits?
Question 51: How can an intensive livestock system be designed to reduce the spread of infectious diseases among livestock and the risk of new diseases in humans?
Question 52: How does increasing crop and non-crop biodiversity help pest management?
4. domestic livestock and poultry
domestic livestock and poultry provide a valuable food source [52] and play an important agricultural and cultural role in global society [53-55]. Livestock, often together with crop cultivation, supports almost 1 billion of the world's poorest populations. Given that the livestock sector is the largest user of global land resources (pasture and feed crops account for 80% of agricultural land) and uses 8% of the world's water sources, there is growing concern about the sustainability of livestock production systems [56].
The livestock sector faces many challenges, such as the need to adapt to climate change, which provide favourable or unfavourable environments for particular livestock species and breeds. In addition to carbon dioxide (9%) and nitrous oxide (65%), animal husbandry also produces 37% of anthropogenic methane [56]. Given the diversity of different regions and species, special livestock production systems need to be defined and transactions assessed. A tailored approach must avoid oversimplified solutions for complex and diverse livelihood systems in order to meet the requirements for livestock products to be produced in an environmentally sound and economically sustainable manner. The overarching questions in this section are as follows:
question 53: How should developing countries appropriately develop small and medium-sized livestock industries, taking into account environmental impact, economic recovery and food supply factors? What are the key policies to ensure a balance between the two?
Question 54: What are the primary efficiency goals of livestock production systems (e. g., an appropriate mix of production activities within different systems, optimal numbers and types of livestock) in order for agricultural systems to meet the needs of people for livestock products in an environmentally sound, economically sustainable and socially responsible manner?
Question 55: What are feasible and effective policies and interventions to reduce the demand for livestock products in high-consumption societies, and how do these policies and interventions affect the global trade in livestock products and the competitiveness of smallholder livestock systems in poor countries?
Question 56: In addition to preserving livestock production, how can inland and marine fisheries in developing countries produce animal protein in a more sustainable manner?
Question 57: What is the best way to stimulate regional livestock market economic growth while limiting the impact of global climate change? How can industrialized countries improve carbon emissions from their livestock industries?
Question 58: What are the environmental impacts of different livestock and aquaculture systems?
Part III: Agricultural Development
1. Social Capital, Gender Balance and Agricultural Extension
social capital describes the social relationship between culture and economic life, but also includes concepts such as trust and teamwork among people working within the same organization or network. Use each other's communication and interaction to build a relationship to achieve a win-win result of collective mutual benefit. Under the influence of socially recognized codes of conduct and legal constraints, individual good behavior habits are formed, which also promotes collective action and cooperation for the common interests of various groups. It can be seen that social capital is not only an important prerequisite for the adoption of sustainable behaviors and technologies on a large scale, but also a prerequisite for the sustainable management of specific resources and technologies. The way in which farmers participate in the development of agricultural technology and its promotion is the response of farmers to these new ideas. This participation ensures that they directly learn these new technologies and measures, and then adapt to this special agricultural ecology. Socio-economic environment [2]. This process of grower participation in research, field testing, and material selection must be integrated into the system of scientific research, technology extension and development as soon as possible. Agricultural advisory and extension services are important in the overall study of the development process, while a range of market and non-market agents and their agents provide vital services for the welfare of farmers and other rural populations. [4,57]. How to transfer the preference for male labor in traditional agricultural research and development to the level of equality between men and women is not a topic of so-called "political correctness" (political correctness) or ideology, but a question of development efficiency that benefits the whole society. Creating a gender-equitable agricultural research and development system would be a transformative intervention. This kind of intervention will play a huge role in changing opportunities, goods, interpersonal relationships, services, etc., and ultimately can change the way people deal with problems. By understanding the limitations and opportunities of women in the development of agriculture, it is possible to explore a new way to explore women's needs and enhance their role in improving agricultural productivity, ensuring food security and reducing poverty [58]. In addition, there is a need to find a measure of social change and institutional learning. The overarching questions in this section are as follows:
question 59: When agriculture requires a high degree of knowledge-intensification and institutionalization, what are the benefits of diverse and innovative extension strategies? How can institutional change and technological innovation be best adapted to enable the participation and role of the largest number of farmers?
Question 60: What are the new opportunities offered by mobile phones and web-based technologies for agricultural education, agricultural extension, farmer mobility and farmer rights?
Question 61: In addition to State-run agricultural extension services, what models and mechanisms of private sector or co-financed agricultural advisory services can serve farmers excluded from the public sector?
Question 62: What are the effective ways to retain the female workforce in agricultural research and extension institutions and how to ensure that they are able to participate in the planning process of the entire agricultural development and extension system in order to meet the specific needs of women and other broader interests?
Question 63: In order to create a more appropriate, sustainable and innovative agricultural environment, what are the best models of social learning and multi-stakeholder (multistakeholder) participation (e. g. rural field schools, farmers field schools), so that farmers, scholars, experts, business, government and other core sectors can work together to develop better technologies and institutions?
2. agricultural development and farmers' livelihoods
Ensuring the livelihood of the people, especially the livelihood of rural residents, and not just focusing on increasing income, is the principle of many development assistance organizations. It focuses on diverse approaches that can help lift people out of poverty [12,59,60] and also on the important role of agricultural intensification, agricultural and non-agricultural income, agricultural investment, etc. Especially in the BRIC countries (Brazil, Russia, India, China), including in sub-Saharan Africa, "de-De-agrarianization" has become a prominent phenomenon [61]. The ever-expanding problem of food security is closely related to the decline in agricultural investment worldwide and has become a new concern in the agricultural sector. To this end, in April 2010, the World Bank and other donors launched the Global Agriculture and Food Security Initiative and called for a new "green revolution" to boost Africa's development. The environment and climate change are critical to our understanding of agriculture, poverty, development, the way people live and the extent of human intervention. This has been correctly understood and to some extent can be achieved by manual intervention. There is strong concern about food security as a result of climate change. The Consultative Group on International Agricultural Research (CGIAR) has launched a new initiative (see www.ccafs.cgiar.org for details); the importance of ecosystem services is also well reflected in a number of key reports from the World Resources Institute and FAO, which see payment systems for ecosystem services as a possible way to address poverty alleviation among poor rural households [63,64]. However, for each such technology-and market-based intervention, issues such as post-implementation equity, environmental and long-term resilience of smallholders, rural communities and farmers' livelihoods must be considered in advance. The overarching questions in this section are as follows:
question 64: What is the impact of agricultural subsidies in OECD countries on the welfare of farmers in developing countries?
Question 65: What systematic approaches can be used to identify and adopt candidate technologies that can increase land and water use efficiency in rain-fed crops and livestock systems, thereby contributing to poverty eradication under different agro-ecological and socio-economic conditions?
Question 66: In the case of large-scale rural areas and small rural households, how can we take into account the interests of the whole people and weigh the common development of social efficiency, social equity and environmental benefits?
Question 67: What are the best options for improving sustainable intensive agriculture?
Question 68: How can current smallholder agriculture be transformed into sustainable intensive agriculture while sustaining the livelihoods of smallholder farmers?
Question 69: What is the long-term impact of international aid and private enterprise contributions on beneficiaries from the perspective of food security, environmental sustainability, local economy and social inclusion?
Question 70: How can a multidisciplinary framework that integrates scientific innovation and multi-stakeholder expectations be designed and applied to agricultural systems in developing countries?
Question 71: Under what environmental and institutional conditions will increasing biodiversity at the farm and landscape scale increase farmers' livelihoods and incomes?
Question 72: Who else will be working for farmers in 2050 and what will their property rights to the land (land ownership, leasing and management) look like then?
The relationship between 3. government governance, economic investment, power and decision-making
the promotion of agricultural development is facing a serious challenge, namely, how to manage the multiple agendas and collective interests between formal and informal institutions (State, private sector, civil society), including their internal relations, obligations, processes, mechanisms and differences. It is precisely at this level that governance, investment, power, and decision-making converge and cross, playing their respective important roles. In terms of governance, it is very important to establish a system of risk and insurance guarantees for the welfare and socio-economic interests of small farmers, an area in which the State has an important influence because of its ability to influence technology and policy. Thus, external assistance and delivery modalities and national policy guidelines are important topics [4,6]. The rapid growth of agriculture and rural areas requires complementary investments from large-scale mechanized intensive production systems to a single farm unit, I .e. covering the entire agricultural production system. Therefore, the optimal integration of state and private sector investments in irrigation and water resources management, rural road construction, agricultural finance and extension services is even more important for the formation of intensive agricultural systems [65]. Given the extremely adverse effects of climate change on the productivity of different agro-ecosystems, it is imperative that, in addition to investment in infrastructure, the resilience of crops and cropping systems be carefully considered [66]. The overarching questions in this section are as follows:
question 73: What are the consequences of countries with low per capita income but rising political players (such as Brazil, China, India and Indonesia) acting on the global food system with their increasing economic levels and purchasing power, in turn, for themselves?
Question 74: What should be the effectiveness of multilateral and bilateral donor delivery modalities to increase the welfare and productivity of smallholder farmers in developing and poor countries?
Question 75: Under what circumstances would abandoning investment in large-scale or mechanized agriculture and increasing investment in smallholder farmers lead to greater social and environmental benefits?
Question 76: In the construction of irrigation infrastructure, what are the different effects of multiple and different mixed public-private investments?
Question 77: What are the different outcomes of different investment options for investing in the resilience of agroecosystems to cope with the negative effects of multiple climate changes?
Question 78: What measures are needed to encourage young people to study agricultural science?
Part IV: Markets and Consumption
1. food supply chain
the food supply chain (FSC) encompasses all activities from field production to consumption. Since 1950, the food supply chain has undergone fundamental changes and is becoming more and more global, and the scale of production, the production line of processed products, and the economic concentration of the sector are all rising. As a result, the regulation of the food supply chain has become more complex and diverse, involving many public, private and civil society actors [67].
Over the past two decades, the basic trajectory of power within the food chain has been a steady shift downstream towards the major food partner retailers. This trend is becoming increasingly clear. [68]. Food sales in most industrialized countries are now 3/4 primarily through supermarkets. This has led to critics criticizing the environmental impact of low-cost supply chains throughout the year. However, this retail model is becoming more common in many developing countries and is growing rapidly globally [69], while increasing attention is being paid to its impact on diets [70].
The key task is to understand exactly what "sustainable food" stands for and to identify best practice standards for activities across the entire food supply chain. Life cycle assessments and other technical measures are needed to assess energy, water and carbon footprints and other environmental impacts; similarly, social, economic and ethical criteria need to be used to evaluate what constitutes the best deal [71,72]. Finally, the aim is to better demonstrate the link between diet and environmental impact, [73] as well as the link between diet and social impact, in order to encourage more people to reflect their responsibilities and behavioural changes in the development of sustainable food supply chains [74]. The overarching questions in this section are as follows:
question 79: How can harmonized sustainable food standards be established and implemented in regional trade organizations such as the EU or NAFTA to safeguard the environment, health (nutrition), food quality and social values, and how can consumer food purchasing behavior be shaped through effective discussion of this issue?
Question 80: What is the position of food waste in the food chain in developed and developing countries, and what measures can be taken to significantly reduce food waste?
Question 81: How can the resilience of the food chain be enhanced in response to exogenous dynamical changes (e. g., increases in hydrocarbon prices) and shocks (e. g., disruptions in air transport)?
Question 82: What is the potential contribution of "localized food production (localized food production)" to the overall sustainability of the food system?
Question 83: How can a standard be set to limit the per capita meat consumption of a population, taking into account population and economic growth, and the impact of the presence of global livestock stocks, in particular on feed demand and waste levels?
Question 84: What are the best indicators that can be used to define thresholds for sustainable agricultural development (e. g. soil conditions, biodiversity, nutrient cycling, energy use, key biological processes (e. g. pollination)) and how are they reflected in the food chain?
Question 85: What are the best institutional mechanisms for managing food stocks, storage, distribution and entitlement systems to ensure their permanent and sustainable supply?
Question 86: How can the commercial development of crops (based on the calories of the seven major crops of wheat, rice, maize, potato, soybean, cane sugar, sugar beet) be expanded to enhance the resilience of the food chain while maintaining the genetic diversity of crops and their wild relatives?
Question 87: How much land in an agro-ecological zone should be provided as habitat for natural organisms to provide ecosystem services and mitigate the threat of climate change?
2. prices, markets and trade
in recent decades, domestic food production and consumption patterns have become interconnected with global markets, and countries now rely on international and domestic markets to distribute food to their people and to allocate inputs for food production. In 2008, the cost of global food imports exceeded $1 trillion billion, a substantial increase over the previous two years [75]. The new food economy means that small changes in production can lead to large price fluctuations. Most countries now rely on buying food in open global food markets; however, when national governments seek to protect their own supplies, the global market chain will collapse [6].
During the period 2007-2008, world food markets experienced a surge in the prices of many important agricultural commodities, including wheat, maize and rice. The reasons have been attributed to accidental factors such as declining regional agricultural productivity, declining global grain stocks, speculative trading and the imposition of trade barriers [76,78]. The price boom has led to riots in Morocco, Mexico, Indonesia and elsewhere. This political instability stems from some short-term pressures, but it highlights a long-term problem of food security and the impact on people's welfare [6], especially as low-income families spend 75% of their income on food [79]. In the coming years, policy research will play a crucial role in the design of mechanisms and measures to reduce or mitigate the impact of market failures. The overarching questions in this section are as follows:
question 88: In the poorest developing countries (especially in sub-Saharan Africa), what are the development priorities that would facilitate efficient market inputs and outputs?
Question 89: As energy prices rise, how can we increase the efficiency of its use and use fewer inputs and fertilizers in agriculture to maintain a sustainable economy and a good environment, while still feeding a growing population?
Question 90: How can a mechanism be designed to enable farmers to withstand market volatility and its attendant risks? How can multiple different mechanisms work best together?
Question 91: How can a market-based food supply system be developed so that stakeholders in the food chain (e. g., farmers, producers, and retailers) provide financially sustainable economic returns while providing consumers with safe, nutritious, and natural-resource-affordable food?
Question 92: What mechanisms can be used to encourage investment in sustainable, high-yield agriculture and to maintain ecosystem services?
Question 93: What institutional capacity can be used to create an efficient and equitable global marketing system to make food production economically and ecologically efficient and to achieve food security through appropriate transactions?
Question 94: How can a domestic food security policy be designed that is compatible with international open markets, while also protecting the interests of national farmers and the right to equal access to food?
3. consumption patterns and health
In recent years, increased purchasing power, changing food preferences and accessible global markets and a growing population have led to significant changes in consumption patterns that will continue to change for the foreseeable future decades. By the end of this century, daily per capita calorie consumption will increase from 2280 kcal in the 1860 s to 2800 kcal. In addition, annual per capita meat consumption increased from 11kg per year in 1967 to 24kg three decades later [80]. As income levels rise in developing countries, per capita demand for meat is expected to converge towards annual per capita consumption of 115kg in the United States and 80kg in Europe [6]. In China alone, meat consumption has doubled in the past 20 years and is expected to double again by 2030. As a result of growing demand, meat production will increase from 229 million tons in 1990 to 465 million tons, and dairy products from 580 million tons to 1043 million tons by 2050 [56]. Changes in the structure of consumption associated with population growth have led us to anticipate that food production will need to increase substantially to meet future consumption needs [80]. Rapid dietary changes (meaning meat-based) make it difficult to provide the kind of balanced diet that can be obtained from grains and other vegetable products. Increased consumption of meat and dairy products (especially red meat), coupled with modern, highly processed food products characterized by high sugar and fat foods, may lead to malnutrition and increasing obesity and its associated diseases, such as type 2 diabetes and chronic heart disease. This will increase the demand for health care and the corresponding increase in consumption [6]. The overarching questions in this section are as follows:
question 95: How will predictable changes in meat consumption in different countries affect the range of agricultural demand?
Question 96: What information is most useful for consumers to make informed decisions, and is there a way to encourage and promote healthy food consumption through interventions?
Question 97: Under what circumstances can government health policies successfully influence consumer eating habits by providing good food as preventive medicine?
Question 98: What plan (or combination of plans) can most effectively promote the demand for healthy food in different socioeconomic groups?
Question 99: What are the effects of experiential learning programs (e. g., garden learning, wilderness therapy, forest schools, outdoor learning) on promoting child nutrition, healthy child development, and preventing obesity and diabetes?
Question 100: Let consumers understand the production process of products, and their consumption choices will be more wise, thereby effectively promoting environmentally friendly food production methods. Including the network of farmers direct sales, food trademark design, farm websites and other information channels for consumers to understand the effect of agricultural production?
4. Discussion
apply the prospect screening approach described in this paper to obtain 100 of the issues considered to be most critical for global agriculture and food security. If these questions are answered, it is expected to have a significant impact on agricultural production on a global scale, while improving synergies between agricultural policy, practice and research. These questions are broad and designed to be answered in a realistic research design that covers 14 topics that need to be prioritized for global agricultural development. Compiled by representatives and experts from the world's leading agricultural organizations, professional scientific associations and academic institutions. The authors hope that these questions will guide policy makers in guiding future agricultural policy research, that researchers will guide their efforts and priorities, and that they will build an organized dialogue among the groups of experts in this paper. However, the prospect screening approach used in this paper also has some shortcomings. The list of final issues is inevitably generated from the initial submission of 618 issues, following the process of ranking, rewording and voting by the caucus members and process. By consulting with a large group of experts with diverse expertise from a wide range of organizations, we hope to minimize the effects of personal preferences and targeted choices. One of the greatest challenges encountered throughout the research process is to draft these questions that can be answered through research design and, through classification, can cover a wide range of issues related to all scales of the global agro-ecosystem [23,24]. The questions were rephrased to ensure clarity and brevity, and the final list of questions undoubtedly obscured the complexity of some of the issues. However, we believe that by designing a research strategy to explore these problems or some of their components in depth, most of the problems can be broken down into several components or projects, and can be further modified to suit specific social, ecological and economic circumstances. What needs to be done now is to design action plans with different priorities around the world and to assess their impact through effective mechanisms and metrics. By listing these issues, we hope to contribute to the dialogue between scientists, producers and policy makers to promote future research and exchange (discourse) in agriculture, as well as to guide researchers in sequencing their own research efforts and formulating direct research plans. We hope that these issues will guide policy makers to look to support and guide future agricultural research; and funding agencies and organizations to look to their funding goals and support for agricultural science. Improving the dialogue and flow of information between policymakers and scientists is essential if agriculture is to overcome the pressures of multiple drivers due to population growth, dietary shifts, energy shortages and climate change. The agricultural sector is now at the heart of an unprecedented integrated driving force, and evidence-based decision-making is essential to overcome the lack of understanding between agricultural research and policy orientation, and to promote cooperation across the sector.
References (omitted)
The top 100 questions of importance to the future of global agriculture. International Journal of Agricultural Sustainability, 2010, 8(4): 219-236
translated by Wang Songliang and Cao Zhiquan
**The authors of the original text include 55 well-known professors and experts from 21 countries around the world, but up to 50 well-known academic institutions and scientific associations.
