Report on the Evaluation Results of the 2020 Essay and Paper Submissions

Notices

China Foreign Agricultural Economic Research Association 2020 essay and paper evaluation results report.

The China Foreign Agricultural Economic Research Association launched the 2020 essay and paper evaluation activities in February 2020. The theme of the essay is "Agricultural and Rural Development in the Post-well-off Society-International Experience and Transformation Direction", with six topics including agricultural and rural policies and comparisons in high-income countries. A total of 80 unpublished contributions were received in this essay solicitation activity. According to the author's qualification and topic selection relevance review, all of them are qualified to participate in the paper evaluation.

In late July, the essay writing working group standardized and anonymized the submitted papers, and divided the papers into three groups at equal intervals. Nine experts were selected from the expert database and divided into three groups according to 3 people in each group, and the three groups of papers were scored by two-way anonymous preliminary evaluation. The scoring is based on a percentile system, and the six aspects of topic selection, content, technology and methods, academic standardization, readability and innovation are evaluated. The score ranges are 0-15, 0-20, 0-20, 0-20, 0-15, 0-15 and 0-15, respectively. The average score of the three experts in the group is the score.

Among the 80 submissions, there are not only empirical research papers on econometrics, but also theoretical analysis and case study papers, and the number of papers related to foreign and international agricultural and rural research has increased significantly. The topic selection, research content, technology and method, academic standardization, etc. of the submitted papers are good, and the quality level is high. Judging from the scoring results, the scoring gap between the three groups is not large; there is a significant gap between the three experts in the group. In response, the secretariat used a normalized approach to process the results of the scores, which reduced the gaps in the scores of different experts between groups and within groups. The normalized scoring results are more fair and consistent.

According to the normalized scoring results and the comprehensive factors such as the correlation with the purpose of the study, the principle of strict quality was adopted, and 12 of the papers with good evaluation were praised. Unpublished and unsubmitted praise papers will be recommended to journals such as "China Rural Economy", "China Rural Observation", "Reform", and "World Agriculture" after seeking the consent of the author. After the recommendation, each journal will handle it independently according to its review process.

Attached: List of Papers for Praise in 2020 Annual Meeting

secretariat of China Foreign Agricultural Economic Research Association

14 August 2020

list of Papers Praised for 2020 Annual Meeting

(sorted by normalized average)

serial Number

author's Name

author Unit

title

1

hu Yuan, Liang Yixin

college of Economics, Sichuan Agricultural University

rural Poverty Governance after 2020: Object Definition and Governance Ideas

2

sun Zhilu, Li Xiande, Li Sijing

institute of Agricultural Economics and Development, Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences

research on Intra-industry Trade of Agricultural Products and Its Influencing Factors between China and Countries along the Belt and Road

3

zhang Ouxiang, Lu Lianghua

anhui Agricultural University

ternary Marginal Characteristics of China's Tea Export Trade Growth and Its Decomposition

4

min Yang, Aizhi Yu, Gaomi

school of Economics, Central University of Finance and Economics, et al

research on Sino-US Economic and Trade Relations, Agricultural Production Shock and Trade Transfer Effect

5

chen Zhe, Li Xiaojing, Xia Xianli

college of Economics and Management, Northwest Agriculture and Forestry University

socioeconomic Status, Dual Learning and Farmers' Adoption of Biological Control Technology

6

wang Ganrun, Buwaa Abra

college of Economics and Trade, Xinjiang Agricultural University, et al

research on the Development of Cotton Products Trade between China and Countries along the Silk Road Economic Belt Based on the Evolution of International Division of Labor from the Perspective of the Whole Industry Chain

7

zhu Senlin, Li Gucheng

college of Economics and Management, Huazhong Agricultural University, et al

can Education Improve Fertilizer Utilization Efficiency in China

8

xiao Weidong, Gong Huizhen, Wang Bingjie

school of Public Administration, Shandong Normal University

building the Financial Foundation and Important Pillars for the Implementation of Rural Revitalization Strategy -- The Beneficial Enlightenment of EU Financial Support for Agricultural and Rural Development

9

he Zhipeng, Yu Kang, Liu Qiang, Li Lei

college of Economics and Management, Zhejiang Agriculture and Forestry University, et al

does the relocation of children help improve the nutritional intake of migrant workers in cities?

10

ye Feng, Li Gucheng, Li Ou Nan

college of Economics and Management, Huazhong Agricultural University, et al

can the Reform of Collection and Storage System Promote the High Quality Development of Corn

11

xu Jiabin, Wang Yang, Li Cuixia

college of Economics and Management, Northeast Agricultural University, et al

impact of Dairy Farming Industry Agglomeration on Environmental Efficiency in China

12

wang Quanzhong, Li Yu

school of Economics and Management, Anqing Normal University, et al

the Diversified Pattern of Helping Subjects and Poverty Reduction

Attachments